Florida Immigration Bill Appears Dead For 2011

TALLAHASSEE (CBSMiami/NSF) – A vast difference between House and Senate versions of a Florida immigration bill means it is likely the issue is dead for the 2011 legislative session, according to the Florida House sponsor of the bill.

The Senate’s rejected a tougher House immigration proposal Tuesday with lawmakers unable to agree on an issue that split the Republican Party like few others.

After a long, emotional debate on Tuesday, the Senate advanced an immigration bill that does not penalize businesses for hiring undocumented workers and sets a higher standard than the proposed House bill before police can check an immigrant’s status.

With bills so dramatically different and the legislative session scheduled to end Friday, Rep. Will Snyder said it would be almost impossible to get the 80 votes needed procedurally to get the measure through the House at this late date.

“We had a majority for my bill,” said Snyder, R-Stuart, expressing disappointment that the measure is likely dead until next year. “The people of Florida expected we would do something about it.”

Senators may still vote Wednesday on the bill, which backers said was forced on Florida by a lack of action in Washington. The measure fell short of Arizona-style restrictions now tied up in court, but was still a flash point in the last week, with a near-constant protest from immigrants and immigrant rights group at the Capitol.

“Where we stand here today is caused by an absolute failure of our federal government to come to terms with a fair, equitable and reasonable way to handle these issues,” said Sen. JD Alexander, R-Lake Wales, a farmer, who was handed sponsorship of the bill late in the session.

But the Legislature appeared unlikely to be able to come up with a fair way to do it either. The measure pulled the GOP three ways. Many Hispanics in the Legislature – most of them Republican – were uncomfortable with some elements of the proposal. But it was pushed by the populist wing of the Republican Party, including tea party backers, who have made immigration one of their top issues.

But perhaps the most interesting element of the debate came from a third Republican constituency, big business – and particularly the agriculture industry – which expressed concerns about the impact of the message that a crack down on immigrants would send in a tourism-dependent state, and the effect on the state’s workforce.

Tuesday’s debate underscored the difficulty Florida officials face in crafting immigration policy. The state’s tourism, agricultural and construction industry are dependent upon immigrant labor –both legal and illegal – to take jobs that U.S. citizens won’t fill.

Following more than two hours of debate on Tuesday, the Senate rejected on a 16-23 vote, a proposal that would have forced businesses to use the federal E-verify system to check immigration status, or face the possibility of fines up to $1,500 for per violation for employing workers who are in the country illegally. Backers said the amendment was essential to ensure that only those legally in the country are being hired. The House had wanted a requirement for immigration checks on all new hires.

The House measure (HB 7089) would allow law enforcement officers to seek the immigration status of suspects in criminal investigations. The bill also would sanction employers who do not use the E-verify system and hire undocumented workers.

On Tuesday, immigrants in the Senate spoke against taking a hard line on the issue. Florida’s recent history is replete with examples of immigrants who came and made a contribution, said Sen. Gwen Margolis, D-Sunny Isles.

“What is happening in this state?” said Margolis, 76, choking back tears. “In Dade County everyone speaks another language. You can’t get a job if you don’t speak another language. That’s the way it is. That’s the way we live. That’s where I grew up.”

  • Vincent Marinello

    I will never cast my votes again nor will i ever recommend to someone to serve in the armed forces such as I did…………..You let us down Goc Scott

  • Rodriguez

    I am all for the immigrants, but here in Miami it is costing our hospitals and schools billions of $$$ to care for the illegal immigrants.

  • jan

    that is a bunch of bull-that americans won;t take these jobs. you know what? unemployment is so high, most of these unemployed americans would take any job they could get. this is an excuse from businesses to hire these people as cheap as they can and treat them not so good. it ticks me off seeing nothing but immigrants in every service job (retail, fast food etc) americans did these jobs before these people came to our country, so why woudln;t they take these jobs now? the other bad thing is most of the immigrants with these jobs do not speak good english –tio hard to communicarte with them ….we cater too much to having spanish almost as a first language. this is the untied states-our official language is english–you choose tol ive here, please speak it. if i moved to another country, i would learn their language.

    • Leo

      That’s BS their r a lot of jobs that do not pay well and no one wants them, and I mean Americans. I see a bunch of young Americans on the streets begging know that McDonald’s always is hiring or a janitorial job or go pick strawberries, they wont do it, so don’t even blame it on the immigrants. They don’t take these jobs now because they don’t pay enough. You are the most ignorant person I know, where you come from? You might have been born here but your roots come from immigration. You are one reason why their is hate in this country.

  • MiamiMex

    Big Businesses make a fortune by hiring illegals.

    Then the taxpayers have to pay for their hospital care, schools, etc.

  • Let's Be Honest

    Jan, Did you know that employers who use the H2A guest worker program (for agriculture) must advertise, offer and give the job to American workers (good, bad or in between) before they are allowed to bring in any temporary, foreign workers. In addition, under the program they don’t pay minimum wage or below as many like to claim, but something known as the adverse effect wage rate – which in Florida is currently above $9.50/hour. And for that $9.50/hour, those Americans can work hard, or hardly work and those employers still have to keep them. In addition, they must provide them with housing and transportation to and from work. And yet, I can tell you that there are VERY, VERY FEW Americans willing to do that work. Even at $9.50 an hour. I’m not a supporter of illegal immigrants – but I am a supporter of the facts and the truth.

  • jan


    • Leo

      You are an ignorant person, look what happened in Arizona their Economy is worth because they had to close half the businesses down because they have no workers, because they lazy ass Americans don’t want the jobs. Get a life…

  • Love USA..

    We elected Them..& They,Afraid & Defend,the Illegals..Crazy….Cowards Politicians???

  • JOHN

    the govern race was won by the biggest liar rick scott you fooled us all .shame on us for voting for you .your now a one term governer we wont fall for that again.lets get to work .what a joke .the teachers,students,hard working americans the fire department police all take a hit BUT NOT IMMAGRATION .american have no rights GOVERNMENT THINK FOR US .RUNNING THIS COUNTRY INTO THE GROUND WHILE WE WATCH

blog comments powered by Disqus
Connect With Those In Need
Weather Forecast 24/7

Listen Live