DAVIE (CBSMiami) – At this point in the season, the joke of why shouldn’t you give the Miami Dolphins players a dollar…because they will only give you three quarters back seem apropos.

The Dolphins’ latest games are a microcosm of the entire season. The Fins have started off the games well, and then quickly faded until losing all hope at the end of the game/season.

READ MORE: Car Smashed Into Fort Lauderdale Business, Driver Taken To Hospital

Since the Dolphins started out 3-0 in 2013, the Fins have been outscored 53-23 in the fourth quarter of games. They haven’t even smelled the end zone in the fourth quarter since scoring a touchdown in September.

“It’s probably more frustrating than if they put 50 points on the board,” defensive end Cameron Wake said. “You know for 56 minutes of the game you are doing everything you can, and you are doing everything you need to do to win the game. Again, that last five or so minutes, where the play needs to be made, we kind of let it slip through our fingers. It’s frustrating to know the capability and ability is there, and guys are making it happen, but in critical positions we dropped the ball.”

Wake was literal in his comment as Mike Wallace let a Hail Mary pass slide off his fingers at the goal line in the final seconds of the Dolphins’ latest defeat. The loss plummeted Miami into a six-way tie in the AFC at 5-6 on the season. The logjam of teams are fighting for the last AFC Wildcard spot.

The Dolphins’ latest loss was reminiscent of a defeat at New England on Oct. 27, when they blew a 17-3 halftime lead. This time they were at home, dominating a team that had won six consecutive games.

Carolina’s comeback began in the final minute of the first half, when Dolphins coaches made the dubious decision to deploy a prevent defense. Soft coverage allowed Cam Newton to complete a swing pass for 29 yards, setting up a field goal on the last play before halftime that made the score 16-6.

On Monday, defensive coordinator Kevin Coyle took the blame for ordering the prevent defense against Newton.

“I made a call that in retrospect I wish I could get back,” Coyle said. “We were playing for him to throw the ball deep, and it was my mistake. It wasn’t the players.”

READ MORE: 'Waiting To Get Your Booster Is A Bad Idea': Local Experts Weigh In On Omicron COVID Variant

The fourth quarter was worse. Leading 16-13, the Dolphins were likely one play from victory when Carolina had a fourth and 10 at its own 20 with 2½ minutes to go.

Newton threw a 19-yard completion, and the Panthers went on to score the winning touchdown.

“We had to stop them at the end, and we just didn’t close,” defensive end Jared Odrick said. “We didn’t finish.”

The Dolphins have lost six of their past eight games, and their fourth-quarter statistics during that stretch are dismal. They’re a minus-three in turnovers, and they’ve been outgained by 226 yards. Ryan Tannehill has one touchdown pass, five interceptions and 17 sacks. Wallace is averaging 8.9 yards per catch with no scores.

“We’ve got to make plays when they count,” Wallace said. “We kill ourselves.”

The Dolphins have showed they can win close games — their past four victories have all been by a total of 14 points. But they’ve also lost four games by a total of 12 points.

“Most of our games this year have been tight,” tackle Tyson Clabo said. “The games we’ve won, we made the plays down the stretch. And the games we lost, we didn’t.”

MORE NEWS: Missing North Miami Beach Teen Jeimy Henrriquez Has Been Found

(TM and © Copyright 2013 CBS Radio Inc. and its relevant subsidiaries. CBS RADIO and EYE Logo TM and Copyright 2013 CBS Broadcasting Inc. Used under license. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.)