Cracks Found In New Marlins Ballpark Garages, Repairs To Delay Completion

LITTLE HAVANA (CBS4)- Hundreds of hairline cracks have appeared on support beams along exterior walls of Miami’s four parking garages at the new Little Havana ballpark for the Marlins.

Officials said the cracks will be repaired in time for the garages to be in use for the team’s season opener in April 2012.

The two-foot cracks have been found on the inside of the outer walls of the structures, and developed because the support beams there are tied into the exterior walls on only one of their two sides, according to CBS4 news partner The Miami Herald.

“They miscalculated some of the load,” Robert Fenton, the city’s project manager, said Friday.

Fenton was referring to the Leo A Daly Co., the Omaha, Neb.-based international architecture firm that the city hired to design the five- and six-story structures that will provide two million square feet for 5,000 cars and a host of retailers.

Alice Bravo, Miami’s director of capital improvements, said Leo A Daly has “accepted responsibility” for the error and has agreed to cover the repair cost, which could amount to $1 million.

Abdel Martel, Daly’s vice president and director of operations, agreed Friday his firm was responsible for the repairs, but said the design work at issue had been carried out by a subcontractor, the Herald reported.

The city is paying about $75 million to build the garages.

According to the Miami Herald, the cracks were discovered in March by a building inspector hired by the city. Officials of the city and the design firm have spent the past three months evaluating the problem. Fenton estimated the repairs will take a team of 8 to 10 workers from four to six weeks for each building, which will delay completion of the garages until December, further tightening an ever-shrinking construction window.

Slideshow: Marlins Stadium Construction

The city is contractually obligated to have the garages in place a month before play begins next April at the shiny, glass-encased new stadium at the former Orange Bowl site. Miami Mayor Tomas Regalado said Thursday the cracks “won’t threaten opening day.”

“We have no concerns whatsoever,” Marlins spokesman P.J. Loyello said Friday.

Fixing the cracks will require boring into the concrete, inserting new steel rebar rods, and pouring more concrete into the holes for added support. The fix also requires a square block of concrete that will extend a few inches from where the cracks are on the exterior walls.

Bravo and Fenton say the cracks pose no danger, and the concern is that water may seep into them and, in time, soften the concrete, eventually shortening the lifespan of the garages from their expected 50 to 75 years.

John Pistorino, of Pistorino & Alem Consulting Engineers, said that without seeing the plans or the cracks, it was difficult for him to comment on the problem. But it appears, he said, the city is trying to protect the structure from a long-term problem known as spalling, which occurs when water creeps in and causes the rebar to rust and expand, further cracking the concrete and destabilizing it. Spalling usually doesn’t occur for many years.

“It’s a pretty common concern in the industry,” said Pistorino, whose firm is now building a Metrorail extension near Miami International Airport. “It takes some time for that to happen, though. They’re trying to avoid it.”

Fenton, the city’s project manager, said spalling is commonly seen on eroding balconies on Miami Beach condos, where the salt also eats away at the structure. “It’s not an immediate concern. But if we’re not to address the cracks, that’s where the lifespan [of the garages] comes into play.”

Building $75 million worth of parking facilities is part of Miami’s contribution to the $615 million, 37,000-seat, retractable-roof complex. The city will put another $25 million into construction and utility repairs. The ballpark is being built with a combination of $359 million in tourist taxes and bond money from Miami-Dade County, and $155 million from Florida Marlins owner Jeffrey Loria, who will borrow $35 million of that from the county, the Herald reported.

The county will own the stadium. The Marlins’ roughly $2 million a year lease payments will be applied against its debt to the county.

The Marlins — who have already lost 20 games this month heading into Friday night’s game in Seattle, and chronically struggle to attract fans — say they need the new facility to remain viable. However, leaked private financial statements show the team has been the most profitable in baseball the past few years.

(©2011 CBS Local Media, a division of CBS Radio Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. CBS4 news partner The Miami Herald contributed material for this report)

  • ralphgmiami

    The Florida Marlins are the Yoko Ono of baseball. Yoko Ono of course caused the Beatles to break up. Meanwhile the Marlins and their money pit stadium will break the city of Miami and Miami dade county. It will be a money pit becase it has a bunch of windows in order to show the Miami skyline. Air conditioning is very expensive in South Florida. Also it’s hilarious the public relations angle being given that the Marlins are profitable. They don’t spend on payrolll so the honest word that should instead be used is cheap. About watching a baseball game no thanks; there’s no way I’ll watch the boring Marlins. I’ll watch my beloved New York Yankees instead.

  • Cal Howe

    We have some of the very best engineering firms in the world right here in south Florida. It makes one wonder why you would hire a firm from anywhere else. I pity the taxpayers but it shows how money controls no matter what governmental unit is in charge. The new stadium and its parking garages will be held together with band-aids. How sad.

    • Indhy

      Band-aids, spit, and bubble-gum will also be used as they see fit… LOL

  • Mario Roman Jr

    PJ Lorello speaking on behalf of the Marlins says he is happy. Well i guess if PJ and the Marlins are happy then its all worth it. Im just not sure that a large portion of the populace that have lost their jobs and homes will feel the same. Hundreds of millions of dollars spent, so rich millionaires can play with a bat and ball is a disgusting travesty.

  • Carol

    Haste always makes waste no matter what and now they are going to have to redo the support beams I really don’t care how long it takes because lives are at steak.

    And all t hey could do insult the Orange Bowl because it old but it was there forever and there were no cracks anywhere.

  • Phil Landers

    Cracks in the parking garage and crack heads right around the corner.

  • Paddy

    Wow…50 to 75 yr life expectancy??? They sure don’t build ’em like they used to…from throw away cars to throw away buildings…what a waste.
    I know one structure I won’t be going inside of!

  • Chucky

    “…lives are at steak?”

    “… insult the Orange Bowl because it old but it was there forever and there were no cracks anywhere?”


    • cubalibre

      Exactly, huh? Did they make the garage out of meat? Everyone knows the Orange Bowl was a crumbling diaster due to neglect. The “cracks” were part of the deadly charm, not that a bunch of drunk UM fans would know or care….

blog comments powered by Disqus
Weather Forecast 24/7
Thanksgiving Guide

Listen Live