Investigative Panel Meets Friday On Barahona Case

MIAMI (CBS4) – An independent panel of child welfare experts held a meeting Friday afternoon for the first time to discuss one of the worst child abuse cases in South Florida history as it tries to determine what went wrong in the state’s effort to protect Victor and Nubia Barahona.

“This was a terrible tragedy,” said panel chairman David Lawrence in reference to the Barahona case. “And none of us should be permitted to do anything less than learn from it.”

Lawrence, a children’s advocate and chairman of the Children’s Movement of Florida, is a member of the three-person independent investigative panel that will hear testimony about what happened to the Barahona children.

“I met with the secretary of the Department of Children and Families just this morning in Tallahassee and I’m absolutely convinced that he wants to get to the bottom of this and find out what needs to be fixed and the rest of our committed as well,” said Lawrence on Thursday.

DCF Secretary David Wilkins called for a management review of the circumstances that led to death of 10-year-old Nubia and critical injuries to her twin brother, Victor.

In addition to Lawrence, panel members include Jim Sewell, a Department of Children & Families manager who led the 2009 review into the death of Gabriel Myers, and Bobby Martinez, a former top federal prosecutor in Miami.

“Seems like there was an awful lot of eyes on these kids and I know that the school had opinions and I know that there were other professionals that had opinions but again, this was something that was not rushed to or done lightly,” Fran Allegra of Our Kids of Dade-Monroe said.

At one moment, a DCF official said part of the problem is staffing.

“We’ve got a problem with staff turnover. A number of people have left. We had a group leave this fall,” said Peter Digre of DCF.

Lawrence said the panel is taking a closer look at the case and will come up with solutions to prevent this in the future.

“We need to find quickly what went wrong, what needs to be fixed, how we can do this better and that is what we will do,” Lawrence said.

The Blue Ribbon planning said it will hold four other hearings will be held and the panel hopes to have findings and recommendations within a month.

Meantime, DCF investigator Andrea Fleary has been placed on administrative while her handling of the Barahona case is being looked into.

Records show she has been severely reprimanded in the past.

Fleary received a report that Victor and Nubia Barahona were being tortured four days before Nubia’s body was found, but she didn’t call police.

CBS4 news partner The Miami Herald uncovered these previous problems on the job.

Last year she was cited for “poor performance and negligence.” after her handling of a case involving a teenage girl who was repeatedly found naked in bed with her father.

In 2003, Fleary received a “final counseling notice.” when was accused of allowing kids she was supposed to be protecting to visit with a potentially dangerous relative.

“The best you can do in this human world is what specifically happened and how can we make sure this sort of thing doesn’t happen again,” said Lawrence.

He hopes to have a report ready by March 11.

Jorge Barahona, meantime, is charged with attempted first-degree murder and aggravated child abuse for allegedly pouring chemicals on his son, Victor, the same day that Nubia’s body was found in the pickup’s flatbed dead, stuffed in a bag and steeped in unknown chemicals.

Authorities have yet to disclose the cause of Nubia’s death.

Victor continues to recover at Jackson Memorial Hospital’s burn unit. However, health department physician Walter Lambert told a Miami-Dade family court judge Wednesday that Victor may be discharged from the hospital on Friday.



    • sadlad

      First, kudus & God-Bless to the guy who stopped even in the stench of chemicals to save that boy’s life! YOU are the only hero among the adults in this tragedy. Why did they quote their Guardian Ad Litem??? That clueless wit did NOT represent their best interests!!. The GAL program needs GOOD effective volunteers. Acting as though this volunteer did an acceptable job representing the best interests of these kids just to avoid scaring away potential volunteers is CRIMINAL! First thsese poor kids get adoptdumped by DCF, then the big Social Worker Head tries to downplay the horrorific effects of such treatment by chirping away to the media about how happy they are.! What an ass-covering low-life creep! The ends do not justify the means. All the adults involved in putting together this travesty are responsible for being asleep at the wheel. They need to admit or be doomed to continue this nightmare as has been going on with DCF/CFS for years. You can change the name and claim children are “happy” & deny this was yet another travesty bred by a broken system,
      but the truth is clear to the rest of us.

  • maria

    I would like to know how many “Final Repremands” take to get someone off children’s cases. Does anyone know??>?

  • southarg

    Two common threads appear in horrific child abuse across the nation: 1. Parents say they are homeschooling the children when they disappear from school and sometimes from anyones sight. 2. Parents say the child has a medical problem when asked about the child’s abnormal physical appearance. New laws and/ or regulations need to be passed or written whereby 1. All home-schooled children must be actually visually seen by authorities periodically. 2. Medical records must be seen by authorities to support the “medical condition” the child supposedly has. All parents or guardians should be happy to comply to root out the ones who are mistreating children. Other wise, there should be no homeschooling or no “medical condition” excuse to child welfare workers. And child welfare workers who accept these statements without proof should be fired and charged with child endangerment.

  • southarg

    Check out the case in Oklahoma!

  • do the right thing for the daughters's sake

    ya there are alot of kids being abused all over America and no one sees it or reports on it only after it’s 2 late then we hear about them

blog comments powered by Disqus
Weather Forecast 24/7
Thanksgiving Guide

Listen Live